Administration And Leadership

Home>Topics>Administration And Leadership
Refine Results
  1. All
  2. Magazine Articles
  1. Illinois Patient Navigator Pilot Program Successfully Redirects Non-Emergent Patients - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    Subscribe | Newsletters | Advertise | Contact Us             Journal Supplements Subscribe Jobs Featured Jobs Search Jobs Post A Job Products Buyer's Guide Product Reviews Hot Products Hot Products Submissions Product Announcements Product Videos Technical Digests Webcasts White Papers Videos Ask the Expert Education & Training EMS 10 Interviews EMS Today Fitness JEMS Games Product Spotlight Home About Us Advertise Contact Us Our Team Authors Community Submit A Press Release News Patient Care Airway & Respiratory Cardiac & Resuscitation Trauma Administration & Leadership Communications & Dispatch Documentation & Patient Care Reporting Training Operations Ambulance & Vehicle Ops Equipment & Gear Rescue & Vehicle Extrication Major Incidents Mass Casualty Incidents Terrorism & Active Shooter Mobile Integrated Healthcare   Home About Us Advertise Contact Us Our Team Authors Community Submit A Press Release News Patient Care Airway & Respiratory Cardiac & Resuscitation Trauma Administration & Leadership Communications & Dispatch Documentation & Patient Care Reporting Training Operations Ambulance & Vehicle Ops Equipment & Gear Rescue & Vehicle Extrication Major Incidents Mass Casualty Incidents Terrorism & Active Shooter Mobile Integrated Healthcare Home Illinois Patient Navigator Pilot Program Successfully Redirects Non-Emergent Patients Illinois Patient Navigator Pilot Program Successfully Redirects Non-Emergent Patients Wed, Dec 23, 2015 By Tom Bik, PhD , Dennis Presley, MPA , Dottie Miles, EMT-P The role of patient navigators includes some degree of case management, patient education, social work and advocacy. Photo courtesy Illinois Medical Transportation Innovation Project In today’s rapidly changing healthcare environment, many EMS organizations (and EDs) find themselves squeezed between mandates to provide services and reimbursement rules that only provide payment for “medically necessary” services. Often, 9-1-1 calls for service come from individuals whose conditions don’t require emergency care, but nonetheless must be transported by EMS to the ED. The losses from these non-reimbursable transports are a significant threat to EMS financial viability, create unnecessary stress on EMS staff, and divert resources away from legitimate medical and trauma emergencies. One approach to address this problem has been to explore ways to reduce the number of medically unnecessary or inappropriate calls and to collaborate with transit and healthcare providers to provide access to more appropriate non-emergency services. The potential for a more integrated role for EMS was outlined in “Innovation Opportunities in EMS,” a 2013 white paper drafted by the Departments of Health and Human Services and Transportation. 1  A major component of the model proposed in this paper was to develop systems to divert low-acuity patients away from EDs and into patient-centered medical homes. EMS is often the first point of contact between individuals and the healthcare system, and as such, EMS is well-positioned to intervene in a meaningful way that can improve the delivery of health services while reducing overall downstream costs. [Native Advertisement] Several EMS agencies in urban areas have developed sophisticated integrated systems of EMS triage and service coordination. 2  However, many EMS operations lack the administrative staff and/or financial resources to explore innovative models of integrated care . The design and effectiveness of such programs for EMS organizations of different sizes and organizational structures hasn’t yet been well documented. Preliminary results from a pilot project in Illinois, however, suggest one model of integrated care that may be promising for many EMS agencies. ILLINOIS’ PILOT PROJECT Following a comprehensive assessment of medical transportation needs in the southernmost counties of Illinois, the Illinois Department of Transportation (IDOT) and the Center for Rural Health and Social Service Development (CRHSSD) at Southern Illinois University’s School of Medicine established the Rural Medical Transportation Network (recently renamed the Illinois Medical Transportation Innovation Project [IMTIP]). The purpose of this new collaboration was to improve both emergency and non-emergency medical transportation in order to provide reliable, affordable medical transportation using a “one system” perspective. IMTIP adopted a triad model of integrated care that included representatives from EMS, public transit and healthcare organizations. (See Figure 1.) Regional priorities were identified through a series of focus groups, interviews and mail surveys. One major concern identified by project members was the negative impact that medically unnecessary calls for service were having on EMS agencies. To address this concern, the IMTIP partners chose the patient navigator model, a proactive strategy that could capitalize on the collaboration of project partners. Patient navigators (PNs)— whose role includes some degree of case management, patient education, social work and advocacy—had been used with considerable success in many areas of healthcare, and had already been adopted by several EMS agencies in a few metropolitan areas. 3  It was hoped that by integrating PNs into EMS, 9-1-1 callers who were inappropriately using ambulance services and EDs could be instructed on how to access care from non-emergency transportation and healthcare providers, and social service agencies. In order to test drive the application of the navigator model, the IMTIP proposed a three-year EMS patient navigator pilot program to introduce patient navigators at three downstate EMS organizations. PROGRAM DESIGN & START-UP The three EMS agencies selected to conduct the EMS PN trials varied in their size, ownership type and organizational structure. Significant differences also existed in the population size, socioeconomic status and degree of rurality of their service areas. Start-up dates for the pilots were staggered by one year so that lessons learned from the first adopters would be available to those who followed. Each site developed a set of criteria used to refer clients to the PNs. Referrals are made by the paramedics who are sent to treat and transport 9-1-1 callers. Once a client is referred, PNs contact them to offer assistance in obtaining access to appropriate health service providers, non-emergency medical transportation services, and/or other community resources that will help them avoid future non-emergency 9-1-1 calls. PNs also educate clients on the appropriate reasons for calling 9-1-1 and the services that are available from public agencies and not-for-profit organizations. The participating EMS agencies have considerable flexibility in the specific application of the PN model so that there’s an opportunity to learn from innovations at individual sites. The most important task in initiating pilot site operations was for each agency and PN to establish relationships with the medical, social service and public transit providers in their region. Meetings were held with public transit officials, hospitals, clinics, primary care physicians, social welfare agencies, mental health providers and others to alert these organizations the PNs would be referring new clients to their organizations as part of the PN pilot. All three pilot sites chose RNs to serve in the PN position. These RNs were assigned to the PN position half-time during the pilot period and continued to perform other duties within their agencies. Although their medical expertise and knowledge of community services were necessary for the performance of their PN duties, they also required several important personal characteristics. In order to be successful in negotiating difficult patient needs and diverse agency services, the PNs would need to be outgoing, calm and persistent. Very little equipment was required to launch the PNs at each site. Each navigator was equipped with a tablet computer that was used to take referrals and to track interactions with clients. PNs used Microsoft Excel worksheets designed by CRHSSD staff to record interactions with clients and to calculate estimated savings from the PN program. The PNs also had business cards they could distribute to clients listing a cellphone number clients could use to contact them whenever they had questions or needed non-emergency assistance. PRELIMINARY RESULTS Although a complete assessment of the pilot project won’t be available until the pilot period has been completed, some promising findings are evident from a preliminary review of the information reported from the first two pilot sites. General/recurring pain and falls were among the most frequent reasons for individuals to be referred to PNs at both agencies. Other types of problems resulting in referrals included poor living conditions, clients who were unable to care for themselves, substance abuse and mental health issues. Both agencies had nearly identical percentages (14%) of referrals that were due to clients lacking transportation for their healthcare needs (e.g., trips to doctor’s office or pharmacy). Not surprisingly, many of the clients had multiple contributing conditions and circumstances that resulted in their referrals to PNs. The project was designed to target EMS “super-utilizers,” and did in fact intervene with the most frequent 9-1-1 callers. However, the program also identified many other clients who were in need of intervention from medical providers and social service agencies; it seems clear that having PN “eyes on the ground” proves valuable in identifying individuals and providing services to many who would have otherwise fallen through the cracks of the healthcare system, possibly resulting in emergency situations at a later date. PN interventions were broadly classified as either “educational-based” or “referral-based.” More than half of all PN interventions at both sites were educational-based, often little more than teaching clients about the role of EMS in the healthcare system and the appropriate use of EMS. Indeed, almost 90% of clients at the smaller site and 40% at the larger site required only a single intervention from the PN before reducing the number of times clients made medically unnecessary 9-1-1 calls. Even this minimal amount of targeted effort to improve health literacy helped to significantly reduce the number of unnecessary 9-1-1 calls and to redirect these clients to more appropriate treatment and transportation services. One of the primary motivations for pilot program implementation was to determine whether EMS agencies could improve their financial standing through the use of PNs. A simple assessment of the effectiveness of the program was performed by comparing the number of medically unnecessary EMS trips required by clients who were referred to the PNs six months before and six months after their first contact with the PNs. Preliminary findings determined that the number of calls from clients who had been referred was reduced by more than half at both agencies. (See Table 1.) To place an estimate of the dollar value of the program, the reduction in the number of 9-1-1 calls was multiplied by the average cost of each agency to respond to a 9-1-1 call. Based on preliminary estimates, the cost savings from the reduced number of 9-1-1 calls exceeded $100,000 at both agencies. (See Table 2.) The economic value of other benefits, such as avoiding the cost of unnecessary ED visits, not having to maintain additional EMS crews to service unnecessary calls, or increased revenues to public transportation providers was not estimated in the preliminary analysis. As the program matures and more providers/ collaborators become engaged in the project, other cost savings and improvements in client welfare may emerge. Both participating EMS agencies plan to continue their PN operations after the pilot program has been completed. Proactive PN programs may also provide EMS agencies with a head start in the type of collaborative relationships that are likely to dominate the future of healthcare. PNs at these two pilot agencies are forging relationships with primary care providers, hospitals, federally qualified health centers, public transportation agencies, home health providers, dental clinics, social service agencies and nursing care facilities. Formal agreements and protocols have been established with some of the providers, and resource lists of all referral collaborators have been developed. The performance of the pilot program will continue to be monitored by the IMTIP staff and a research report documenting the complete evaluation will be prepared and released once the pilot period has concluded and all of the data has been analyzed. CHALLENGES REVEALED Preliminary reports from the PNs in the pilot study have also revealed some of the challenges to working in a mobile integrated healthcare delivery environment. PNs must learn to quickly identify patient needs and be able to match these to the types of services available in the community. However, many communities may not have service organizations able to provide the type or quantity of services needed. For example, appropriate outpatient or inpatient mental health services may not be available, or primary care practices may have long waiting lists, especially in smaller communities or rural areas. Integrated care requires a minimum level of local services as well as a high level of cooperation from all service providers. In many areas these services may not yet be available, and providers may just be beginning to develop the level of collaboration that will be needed to serve clients in a fully integrated healthcare environment. The lack of health literacy among large segments of the population also remains a significant challenge. Far too many individuals lack any understanding of the dire implications of inappropriate EMS use. They prefer the quick solution of EMS transport and ED treatment to riding on public transit, making appointments with primary care physicians, or sitting in line waiting for services at outpatient urgent-care facilities. The message of the “9-1-1 quick fix” is inadvertently promoted through TV and news stories, and some ED billboards even advertise short wait times. It will require a substantial health education effort to reverse these attitudes, and educate frequent 9-1-1 users to the true costs of inappropriate EMS use. CONCLUSION Evidence from these pilot projects—as well as the documented success of similar programs— suggests EMS agencies don’t need to wait for national-level policy changes to adapt the way they provide services and improve their financial bottom line. PN programs can provide an opportunity to avoid financial losses from non-reimbursable 9-1-1 calls while improving patient welfare. By leveraging collaboration of service providers in their communities, EMS agencies can alter traditional “siloed” models of healthcare and capture “opportunities for enhanced access, improved diagnosis, patient follow-up and compliance, and enhanced quality of care and patient satisfaction.” 4 REFERENCES 1. U.S. Departments of Health and Human Services and Transportation. Innovation opportunities in EMS [white paper].  National Highway Traffic Safety Administration . Retrieved Nov. 23, 2015, from  www.ems.gov/innovation.htm . 2. Kincaid C. (March 27, 2013.) Navigating Patients Through Healthcare: Transitioning from static to mobile healthcare agencies.  JEMS . Retrieved Nov. 23, 2015, from  www.jems.com/article/administration-and-leadership/navigating-patients-through-healthcare . 3. Fischer SM, Sauaia A, Kutner JS. Patient navigation: A culturally competent strategy to address disparities in palliative care.  J Palliat Med . 2007;10(5):1023–1028. 4. Institute of Medicine. (June 13, 2006.) Future of emergency care: EMS at the crossroads. Retrieved Nov. 23, 2015, from  www.iom.edu/Reports/2006/Emergency-Medical-Services-At-the-Crossroads.aspx . More MIH-CP from JEMS.com By Tom Bik, PhD Tom Bik, PhD, developed a desire to work in rural health while serving as a Peace Corps volunteer in West Africa. He’s worked on a wide variety of research projects including: non-emergency medical transportation surveys, rural water system financial management analysis, rural substance abuse assessment, EMS patient navigator evaluations and others.  Dennis Presley, MPA Dennis Presley, MPA, is the IMTIP coordinator and has worked with agencies and organizations across the state to conduct EMS research and facilitate the relationship between EMS, health care and public transit. He played a major role in the funding, design and implementation of the patient navigator pilot project.  Dottie Miles, EMT-P Dottie Miles, EMT-P, is a paramedic and EMS instructor with nearly 40 years’ experience in EMS, in positions ranging from EMS volunteer to EMS agency director. She also helped to design the patient navigator program and was the director at one of the agencies that participated in the pilot project. She’s currently working to implement a new mobile integrated healthcare pilot project in several downstate Illinois counties.  Sponsored Content is made possible by our sponsor; it does not necessarily reflect the views of our editorial staff. Journal Archives Prev 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 Next Feb 2016 Volume 41 Issue 2 Jan 2016 Volume 41 Issue 1 Prev 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 Next SUBSCRIBE DIGITAL EDITION   Featured Careers More Jobs   eNews Register for the JEMS eNewsletter, it's FREE! Sign-Up! JEMS Connect FEATURED GROUPS Disaster EMS   EMERGENCY! Lovers   Tactical Medicine   Humor In EMS     CURRENT DISCUSSIONS   JOIN JEMS CONNECT   EMS BLOGS Blogger Browser Today's Featured Posts Copyright © 2016: PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved. UTILITY Home About Us Contact Us Terms of Use Subscribe Advertise Reader Service Submit a Press Release RSS Feeds Privacy Policy Topics News Patient Care Leadership Special Topics Major Incidents Operations Sections Authors Columns Community Jobs Journal Products Supplements Webcasts

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Wed, 23 Dec 2015

  2. Workplace Fatigue Creates Dangerous Risks for EMS Employees - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    Coffee can’t combat these hazards.

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Fri, 9 Jan 2015

  3. San Diego’s Resource Access Program Successfully Reduces Costs While Helping Patients - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    Melissa, a frequent 9-1-1 user, was the worst she’d ever been. She’d been transported 16 times in a week and first responders from San Diego Fire-Rescue Department and Rural/Metro Ambulance (SDEMS) were again en route to assess her in a belligerent, intoxicated state.

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Mon, 15 Sep 2014

  4. Bagpipes: Explaining an EMS Tradition - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    In many ways, the last day is always the hardest. Difficult in not only the lengthy undulating miles to be covered under frequently hot and windy conditions, but also in knowing what awaits us at the end of that last mile.

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Mon, 15 Sep 2014

  1. Treat Patients’ Families with Compassion - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Mon, 15 Sep 2014

  2. Learn from Your Superiors to Hone Leadership Skills - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    I’ve been blessed to have many wonderful bosses in my lifetime, and even to have some not-so-wonderful bosses. I’ve learned something from each one, whether it was a direct piece of advice or something I garnered from observing their leadership styles. After all, each one of them was only human and ...

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Mon, 15 Sep 2014

  3. Pro Bono: Responsibility for Patient Belongings in a Disaster - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    When disaster strikes, the EMS provider’s first duty and priority is to aid those in need of treatment and transport. But with the responsibility for patient care may come some degree of responsibility for the patient’s belongings. Patients place huge personal value on their personal items and ...

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Mon, 15 Sep 2014

  4. Is EMS Next to Transition to Medicare’s Value-Based Payment Model? - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    In Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, “value” is defined as “the amount of money that something is worth,” or “usefulness or importance.” America’s healthcare industry is all abuzz with value-based purchasing (VBP) and moving rapidly toward paying for things proven to make a difference in the ...

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Fri, 12 Sep 2014

  5. Be Able to Communicate with All Patients During an MCI - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    When teaching mass casualty incident (MCI) management, I frequently ask participants what the No. 1 problem is at MCIs. Invariably, the overwhelming response is “communications.” They often cite the overcrowding or limited availability of channels and the verbal diarrhea that occurs when personnel ...

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Fri, 12 Sep 2014

  6. Should Naloxone Be Available to All First Responders? - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    Questions to ask when considering expanding the use of naloxone.

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Mon, 11 Aug 2014

  7. Debunking the Myths of Ambulance Restocking Programs - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    As they say, what goes around comes around. Twelve years ago, after hospitals expressed concern that resupplying ambulance services with medications and supplies could be an illegal kickback, the federal government established a “safe harbor” to expressly permit the practice. But recently, it seems ...

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Fri, 8 Aug 2014

  8. Deciphering when Patients Feign Symptoms to Avoid Incarceration - Journal of Emergency Medical Services

    Fuhgitaboudit, spell check. You’ll never find Incarceritis in your laptop’s memory bank. Even if you’ve downloaded a medical dictionary, it would still be of no avail. Stupid computer! Defined as when a patient intentionally falsifies or grossly exaggerates symptoms of illness or trauma in order to ...

    Magazine Articles

    Magazine Articles

    Thu, 7 Aug 2014

Get More Results

Featured Careers

 

eNews

ENLPromo

Register for

the JEMS

eNewsletter,

it's FREE!

JEMS Connect

CURRENT DISCUSSIONS

 
 

EMS BLOGS

Blogger Browser

Today's Featured Posts