Ambulance Rule Faulted in Riverside County (Calif.)

The city of Riverside requires ambulance companies to have a franchise permit & so far has granted a permit for nonemergency calls only to AMR


 
 

ALICIA ROBINSON, THE PRESS-ENTERPRISE | | Monday, December 12, 2011


RIVERSIDE, Calif. -- Riverside officials don't have the right to stop qualified ambulance companies from picking up patients in the city, according to the state agency that oversees county emergency medical service plans.

In Riverside County, all 911 ambulance calls are controlled through a county-approved contract, but county officials say non-emergency transports -- such as trips to dialysis -- are an open market where multiple providers compete for business.

The city of Riverside requires ambulance companies to have a franchise permit and so far has granted a permit for nonemergency calls only to American Medical Response, which also is the county's 911 responder.

City officials contend they haven't limited service to an exclusive provider but say that none of the other applicants met their criteria for service.

The council on Tuesday will consider an application from Los Angeles-based Alpha Ambulance. A committee has recommended denying the permit.

The city's rejection of all other permit applicants means only AMR's ambulances can pick up patients in Riverside. But officials with the California Emergency Medical Services Authority, or EMSA, said Riverside "does not have the authority to restrict trade for interfacility transports within their area" because the county's emergency medical services plan doesn't give the city that authority, according to a written statement from EMSA.

Riverside City Attorney Greg Priamos said Friday that he disagrees with EMSA's assessment.

The issue of ambulance service is a complex and contentious one. Emergency medical services has been an organized, regulated system since only about 1980.

Because of the public interest in fast, reliable ambulance response, the state allowed local governments to create monopolies for 911 service and in some cases for nonemergency, or retail, transports. The state requires each county to have a plan for emergency medical services, and EMSA is charged with reviewing and approving those plans.

STATE STANCE
Under state law, the local EMS agency - in this case, Riverside County - is the only entity with the authority to restrict competition in ambulance service, said Daniel Smiley, EMSA's chief deputy director. If the county's plan was written to allow cities to regulate ambulance companies, then it would be fine - but Riverside's plan isn't written that way, he said.

"We do not believe (the city of Riverside has) the authority to restrict trade in that zone because the (county) plan does not contemplate that at all," Smiley said.

Going outside the bounds of the county's EMS plan could make the city vulnerable to antitrust litigation, Smiley said.

Riverside officials have argued they are not creating a monopoly because ambulance franchises are not exclusive; most applicants simply haven't met the criteria set out in the city's municipal code. One of those criteria is having a county permit, which means the ambulance company has proper equipment, employee certifications, insurance and the like; the other criteria are showing there's a need for another provider, and that allowing more ambulance companies won't economically harm existing providers.

"We do not share EMSA's view in its entirety, and the city continues to believe that it may regulate nonemergency transports in the absence of any conflicting exercise of state or county authority affecting the same activity," Priamos said Friday.

He also cited an October 2010 letter from Riverside County Emergency Medical Services Agency Director Bruce Barton. That letter says any ambulance company with a county permit can provide nonemergency transports anywhere in Riverside County, but it goes on to say any provider must operate "in conformance with applicable state, federal and local laws and regulations."

CITY'S DEFENSE
Priamos said the county has never advised the city that it can't regulate ambulances through franchise agreements.

Earlier this month, Barton said he wanted to speak with county counsel before responding to EMSA's comments. He could not be reached Friday.

So far, no one has formally asked EMSA to weigh in on the issue, and Smiley said the agency doesn't have the responsibility or a mechanism to make Riverside do anything.

If an ambulance provider believes the city is improperly restricting trade, it's up to the provider to take the issue to court, Smiley said.

There have been numerous court cases among ambulance providers, cities and counties over who controls emergency medical services, he said, but he was not aware of case law on the issue that has been raised in the city of Riverside.



Copyright © 2013 LexisNexis, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy


Connect: Have a thought or feedback about this? Add your comment now
Related Topics: News, AMR, American Medical Response

What's Your Take? Comment Now ...

Featured Careers & Jobs in EMS





 

Get JEMS in Your Inbox

 

Fire EMS Blogs


Blogger Browser

Today's Featured Posts

 

EMS Airway Clinic

Simulation-Based Assessment Facilitates Learning & Enhances Clinical Judgment

Simulation is an educational tool that can be used to develop and refine clinical skills of the student in a controlled environment before they progress to becoming practicing clinicians.
More >

Multimedia Thumb

Colorado Medics Ditch Pants for Kilts

“Real men do wear kilts.”
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

NYC September 11 Commemoration

Tolling of the bell begins the anniversary ceremony.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

Wrong Fuel Cited in New Mexico Air Ambulance Crash

Plane received jet fuel instead of aviation fuel.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

Wake County EMS PAT

Physical ability test demonstration.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

CO Leak at Illinois School

Girard incident sends over 130 to hospitals.
More >


Multimedia Thumb

Hands On September 2014

Who gets thumbs up this month?
More >


Multimedia Thumb

NYC Sept. 11 Anniversary

View images from the ceremony at Ground Zero.
More >


Multimedia Thumb

VividTrac offered by Vivid Medical - EMS Today 2013

VividTrac, affordable high performance video intubation device.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

Field Bridge Xpress ePCR on iPad, Android, Kindle Fire

Sneak peek of customizable run forms & more.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

The AmbuBus®, Bus Stretcher Conversion Kit - EMS Today 2013

AmbuBus®, Bus Stretcher all-hazards preparedness & response tool
Watch It >


More Product Videos >