External Review Planned for Alameda Drowning Response; Audio of Communications Released

Acting fire chief said afterward that the firefighters on scene were not authorized to perform water rescues because of budget cuts.


| Thursday, June 9, 2011

ALAMEDA, Calif. (AP) — Officials in the San Francisco Bay area city of Alameda said Tuesday they plan to seek an external review of the actions of police officers and firefighters who stood by as a suicidal man waded into the bay and drowned.

Alameda Mayor Marie Gilmore announced the independent probe at a meeting where nearly two dozen residents accused the city's public safety agencies of incompetence, heartlessness and complicity in the Memorial Day death of 52-year-old Raymond Zack.

"While we appreciate police and fire and know they are doing their own investigation, this has been such an extraordinary situation by any way you could possibly begin to describe it, I know I believe an independent review is warranted," Gilmore said. "The only way the city of Alameda can give our citizens the credible assurance that something like this doesn't happen again is to find out what happened, when it happened and to make changes."

Zack waded into the bay's shallow, 54-degree water fully clothed and remained there for nearly an hour before a female bystander retrieved his lifeless body. By most accounts, up to 75 people, including firefighters and police officers summoned by an emergency call, watched from Crown Beach as he slowly succumbed.

Alameda's acting fire chief said afterward that the firefighters on scene were not authorized to perform water rescues because of budget cuts. The police chief said officers did not have cold water gear and did not know if Zack posed a danger to potential rescuers.

Several speakers at Tuesday's meeting said the incident had shaken their faith in their island city of 74,000 located across the bay from San Francisco.

"Mr. Zack had his hands up, he had his hands up. This is a universal sign of help. At that time he was suffering from hypothermia. We allowed him to die," resident Patty Rose told the council. "I would not let anyone in this room die. I would not allow a dog to drown on that beach, but we killed him. Shame on us."

Daniel Lisker, a retired Oakland Fire Department lieutenant, said the decisions made by the police and fire commanders in charge that day raised troubling questions about the city's ability to protect its residents in the event of large-scale emergencies.

Lisker questioned why the police did not try to communicate with Zack using a bullhorn from shore and the fire department did not ask neighboring departments with certified swimmers or boats for help.

"What concerns me was this incident was an easy to manage incident that turned out tragically for this man because it was not handled professionally," he said.

One witness who was on the beach watching Zack and thought about going in after him until the officers and firefighters arrived said he felt guilty for not intervening.

"I thought, 'Well, the water is very shallow and you would have to go way out, and in the meantime the police and fire would come and they would take care of it," resident Warren Brunetti said. "And within five minutes they did and he was maybe up to his chest and he was standing there. But they didn't do anything."

Acting City Manager Lisa Goldman said 30 firefighters have since volunteered to undergo water rescue training and the city fire chief announced last week that commanders would again have authority to send crews into the bay. The first 16 will start their training next week, Goldman said.

She said the city also plans to make transcripts of all 911 calls and emergency communications before Zack drowned public later this week, along with a timeline of how the events unfolded.

Related Links:

Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Connect: Have a thought or feedback about this? Add your comment now
Related Topics: News, drowning

What's Your Take? Comment Now ...

Featured Careers & Jobs in EMS










Get JEMS in Your Inbox


Fire EMS Blogs

Blogger Browser

Today's Featured Posts


EMS Airway Clinic

The Evolution of Civilian High Threat Medical Guidelines

How mass killing events have proven a need for new guidelines.
More >

Multimedia Thumb

Fire Breaks Out on New Jersey Hospital Roof

Four-alarms in Bayonne for roof top blaze.
Watch It >

Multimedia Thumb

Ottawa Shooting, EMS Audio

Edited audio from the Parliament Hill incident.
Watch It >

Multimedia Thumb

Illinois Ambulance Service on Chopping Block

Peoria Heights EMS depends on property tax vote.
Watch It >

Multimedia Thumb

Kentucky Firefighters, Medics Drill for Ebola

Lexington firefighters and medics prepare for possible patients.
Watch It >

Multimedia Thumb

Ottawa Shooting Incident

Solider is shot by gunman at national memorial in Ottawa.
More >

Multimedia Thumb

Life Link III Trauma Tactics Conference in Minnesota

Conference was designed to enhance the skills of providers of all levels, covering rescue and prehospital situations, to transport and in-hospital treatment.
More >

Multimedia Thumb

EMS Tailgating

Rigs converted for football.
More >

Multimedia Thumb

The AmbuBus®, Bus Stretcher Conversion Kit - EMS Today 2013

AmbuBus®, Bus Stretcher all-hazards preparedness & response tool
Watch It >

Multimedia Thumb

VividTrac offered by Vivid Medical - EMS Today 2013

VividTrac, affordable high performance video intubation device.
Watch It >

Multimedia Thumb

LMA MAD Nasal™

Needle-free intranasal drug delivery.
Watch It >

More Product Videos >