discuss print share

When Minors Can Legally Consent to Urgent Medical Care


W. Ann Maggiore, JD, NREMT-P | Thursday, July 15, 2010

 The term "emancipation" refers to the legal ways in which a minor can gain independence from their parents and adult status for purposes of consent to medical care as well as handling their own legal affairs. All states provide for minors to become automatically emancipated from their parents at age 18. However, for some minors, their family or social situation puts them in a position in which it's preferable to handle their own affairs much earlier than age 18, and they may encounter EMS in situations where their legal status to consent for medical care comes into question.

Whether a minor is legally emancipated is a matter of state law, so it's important to know your own state's laws regarding emancipation. These state laws vary widely: from none at all to a set of circumstances short of a court automatically emancipating a minor.

For example, Indiana has no emancipation laws at all, and minors remain under parental control until they reach age 18. In California, to become emancipated before age 18, a minor must either be married with their parents' permission, be in the armed forces with their parents' permission or have received a declaration of emancipation from a court. This declaration of emancipation requires that the minor be at least 14 years of age, not want to live with their parents, have parental consent and demonstrate that they are employed and able to manage their own finances.

Other states, such as Texas, take a more conservative view by not recognizing emancipation except by court order. In Texas, a minor must be 16 years of age, living on their own and self-supporting in order to obtain emancipation from a court.

In Pennsylvania, in addition to emancipation by court order, a minor can be emancipated by marriage or active duty in the military. Pennsylvania also considers a minor temporarily emancipated if they're in law enforcement custody or in need of medical care and a parent or guardian cannot be located. The law makes specifically the parent or guardian responsible for the cost of medical care rendered under these circumstances.

The confusion for EMS providers often arises when they encounter a minor who is a mother, and they don't know whether that young mother can consent for her child to receive medical care. Many EMS providers erroneously believe that such mothers are somehow "medically emancipated" and can give consent for themselves as well as their babies. However, the answer to this question is generally "no" because having a child is not one of the legal circumstances under which any state recognizes automatic emancipation. In fact, a teen who has a baby is less likely to be able to support herself financially and probably less likely to be able to become emancipated.

In summary, a great deal of confusion in EMS surrounds the status of minors and their ability to consent for medical care. Without question, if a minor is in critical condition, treatment should be rendered and the patient transported to a hospital. The EMS service, the hospital, social workers and attorneys can sort out who is responsible for paying the bill later. More confounding situations arise when a minor patient's injuries are less severe. Don't leave minors by the side of the road or in unsupervised situations after an EMS encounter simply because they are not critically injured and parents cannot be contacted. Be sure to know your own state's laws and develop protocols to deal with these tricky situations.



Related Links:


discuss print share

Related Topics:

Author Thumb

W. Ann Maggiore, JD, NREMT-Pis an attorney and a paramedic in Albuquerque, N.M. She has been a full-time paramedic, an assistant fire chief and a state EMS administrator. Currently, she's a shareholder in the Albuquerque law firm of Butt, Thornton & Baehr, P.C., where she practices law full time, defending physicians, police and EMS personnel against lawsuits. She's a frequent lecturer on EMS legal issues at national conferences and holds a clinical faculty appointment at the University of New Mexico School of Medicine, where she teaches legal issues to faculty, residents and paramedic students. Contact her at desertrose@q.com.

BROWSE FULL BIO & ARTICLES >

blog comments powered by Disqus


Subscribe to JEMS

Love the Site? Get the Journal, Too

Award winning content every month, with features, clinical updates, new product information and much more. Subscribe now!




Get 2 Free Trial Issues of JEMS!

Jems Cover

GET STARTED Print Edition Digital GetStartedWidgetGo


MONOPOLY: EMS Edition, presented by JEMS
Order JEMS' MONOPOLY: EMS Edition & Get $5 Off Shipping
Are You Connected?
Join JEMS Connect

Get JEMS in Your Inbox


Fire EMS Blogs


Blogger Browser

The Quest for High-Quality CPR

Real-time CPR monitoring with feedback showed Henderson (Nev.) Fire Department that its personnel were pushing too fast during CPR. Now, it uses a feedback device to improve CPR effectiveness.
More >


Multimedia Thumb

Md. USAR Travels North

First time team went north for a hurricane.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

Memphis EMT Bails Out On Patient

EMT drops patient off at firehouse instead of hospital.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

3 Dead In Medical Chopper Crash

Names released of fallen crew.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

Detroit EMS Woes

Detroit citizens call 911 a nightmare.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

From the Ground Up

There are many things to consider when planning a building project.
More >


Multimedia Thumb

NYC Mosque Demonstrations

Hundreds protest in New York City
More >


Multimedia Thumb

Simulation Best Practices

This photo gallery illustrates the proper level of environmental fidelity, which is needed to accomplish the learning objectives during simulation training.
More >


Multimedia Thumb

Physio-Control LUCAS Product Demo - EMS Today 2010

The LUCAS 2 delivers compressions according to guidelines.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

TriTech Fusion ePCR Demo - EMS Today 2010

Fusion ePCR streamlines the collection of EMS incident data.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

First Line AmbuBus Demo - EMS Today 2010

AmbuBus is an efficient solution for mass evacuation and transport.
Watch It >


Multimedia Thumb

Mercury Medical Flow-Safe Product Demo - EMS Today 2010

Flow-Safe™ is a disposable CPAP system with manometer.
Watch It >


More Product Videos >


Featured Now on JEMS.com